Fear of getting hurt — how to trust and love again
How to trust and love again — for women who long for love but are afraid of it.
- The fear that protects — and the fear that shuts you in
- Recognise your fear
- Where it comes from
- How fear creates what it fears
- Intuition or fear?
- Self-compassion
- Close the past
- Opening up step by step
- Trust is built on evidence
- When the fear returns in a relationship
- When to seek help
- The 90-day plan
- Sources
The fear that protects — and the fear that shuts you in
Your fear is not a flaw. It is a guard who has forgotten that the war is over.
If you are reading this guide, it has probably happened to you before: you wanted love — and pulled back at the first sign of something serious. Perhaps you chose a man who wasn't available. Perhaps you ended the relationship before he could. Perhaps you told yourself: "Better alone than going through that again."
You are not alone. In psychologist Menelaos Apostolou's research on the reasons for being single, fear of getting hurt was among the most common reasons single people give themselves — and women mentioned it more often than men.
This guide is designed as a conversation with a psychologist. First you will understand where your fear comes from and how it works. Then you will learn how to tell intuition from fear, how to be gentle with yourself and how to open up step by step. At the end, a 90-day exercise plan is waiting for you.
Recognise your fear
Fear rarely says "I'm afraid". More often it says "he's not the one for me".
Fear of getting hurt hides behind sensible reasons. Tick the statements that are true for you:
Two faces of the same fear
Attachment theory describes two ways in which fear of getting hurt shows itself — some women even alternate between them:
| Running away (avoidance) | Running forward (anxiety) | |
|---|---|---|
| Inner voice | "I don't need anyone. Better alone." | "He'll leave me. I have to keep him." |
| What she does | Pulls back when it gets serious; keeps her distance | Clings, checks, needs reassurance |
| Who she chooses | Unavailable men, or nobody at all | Men who are cold — because she has to "win" them |
| What she is really afraid of | That closeness will make her lose herself, or that she will be rejected | That no one will love her just as she is |
Both patterns share the same root: the fear that love means pain. And both are learned — which means they can be unlearned.
This week, do
- Do the self-test and write down which statements stung you most.
- Work out whether your pattern is more "running away" or "running forward".
- Remember the last moment you pulled back. What did you feel in your body?
Where it comes from
The body remembers what the mind would rather forget.
Fear of closeness is not a whim. It is a learned protection that formed because it was once needed. The most common sources are:
- Childhood. Parents who were emotionally unavailable, unpredictable, critical, or who left. A child learns that closeness is dangerous or that love has to be earned.
- A painful relationship or break-up. A relationship in which you gave everything and were abandoned, humiliated or overlooked.
- Being cheated on. A betrayal of trust triggers reactions similar to trauma: hypervigilance, mistrust, searching for signs.
- Watching your parents. If you watched your mother suffer in her marriage, you may learn that love is a trap.
- Violence or abuse. The deepest wounds. For these, professional help is essential (chapter 10).
In the brain, the pain of a break-up resembles physical pain. It is normal to protect yourself afterwards. The question is not whether you are hurt, but whether the wound is still dictating your decisions years later. If you measure every new man against your ex, the story isn't closed yet.
Research shows that betrayal can trigger symptoms similar to post-traumatic stress: vigilance, checking, night-time thoughts. This isn't your weakness — it is the response of a brain that has learned safety is not guaranteed. It doesn't mean all men are the same; it means your brain needs new evidence.
If your first model of love was unpredictable or cold, safe, calm love may feel foreign to you — even boring. The good news: research on "earned secure attachment" shows that adults who had a difficult childhood can develop attachment just as secure as those who had it from birth — through therapy, friendships and good relationships.
After years of being single, fear often dresses up as comfort: "I'm used to being alone, I have my own rhythm." That may be true — or independence may have become a wall. Ask yourself: are you alone because you chose it, or because you're afraid of what would happen if you weren't?
This week, do
- Write down three experiences that taught you love is dangerous.
- For each one, write: what did I learn back then? Is it still true?
- Notice when your body tenses at closeness — and just notice, without judging.
How fear creates what it fears
Whoever expects rejection often gets it — but not because she deserves it.
Psychologist Geraldine Downey studied people who are "rejection sensitive" — who anxiously expect rejection, perceive it quickly and react to it strongly. The result was painful: after one year, 44 % of couples in which the woman was highly sensitive to rejection had broken up, compared with only 15 % of couples in which she was not. Not because these women were less worthy of love, but because of the cycle that fear sets off:
| Step | Example |
|---|---|
| 1. Expectation | "Sooner or later he'll leave me." |
| 2. Searching for signs | He hasn't replied for two hours. "He's already pulling away." |
| 3. Defensive reaction | Coldness, reproach, withdrawal or checking his phone |
| 4. Partner's response | He is confused, feels accused, pulls back |
| 5. "Confirmation" | "See, I knew he'd pull away." |
How to break the cycle
- Catch step 2. When you notice you're searching for signs, tell yourself: "This is my fear, not a fact."
- Check the facts. What do I know for sure? What am I only imagining?
- Ask directly instead of defending. Not "you don't even like me any more", but "I'm feeling unsure today — can you tell me we're OK?"
- Give it time. Most "signs" disappear on their own within a day.
This week, do
- Remember a situation in which you took something as rejection. What were the facts and what was your interpretation?
- The next time you feel worried, wait an hour before you respond.
- Practise the sentence: "This is my fear, not a fact."
Intuition or fear?
The hardest question: when does my inner voice protect me, and when does it shut me in?
Women who have been hurt are often afraid they will miss the warning signs again. So they read every doubt as intuition. The two can be told apart:
| Intuition (listen) | Fear (check) |
|---|---|
| Based on what this man does | Based on what others have done |
| A repeated pattern (he lies, is late, is rude) | A single ambiguous moment |
| Calm, clear certainty | Panic, tension, the urge to act immediately |
| "When he's angry, he humiliates waiters" | "All men cheat in the end" |
| Friends who know him notice the same thing | Your friends like him, but you keep looking for a flaw |
| Around him you feel smaller | Around him you feel vulnerable — because you care |
This week, do
- With every doubt about a man, write down: fact or interpretation? His action, or a memory of someone else?
- Write down three real red flags that would make you leave — and three "red flags" that are really your fear.
Self-compassion
You can't open up to someone else if you are your own harshest judge.
Psychologist Kristin Neff showed that self-compassion — being as kind to yourself as you would be to a friend — improves the quality of relationships. Psychologist David Sbarra followed people after divorce and found that those who spoke about the break-up with self-compassion felt less pain at the start and still nine months later — regardless of self-esteem, attachment style or length of the relationship. Self-compassion isn't self-pity. It is the foundation that lets you get back on your feet.
Exercise: the self-compassion break (3 minutes)
- Notice: "This is a moment of pain." (or: "I'm scared right now.")
- Connect: "Pain is part of life. Other women feel this too."
- Be kind: put your hand on your heart and say: "May I be gentle with myself. May I give myself what I need."
Exercise: a letter to yourself
Write a letter to yourself as a loving friend who knows your whole story would write it. What would she say about what you have been through? About how you protected yourself? About what you deserve?
Stop asking "what was wrong with me". Ask "what did I learn and what do I deserve next time". Guilt keeps you in the past; the lesson takes you forward.
Being cheated on is not proof that you weren't enough. It is proof of his decision. After being cheated on, women often blame themselves because that is easier than accepting that something was out of their control.
The little girl you were couldn't choose different parents. Your defences were clever back then. Now you are an adult and can choose differently — start with tenderness towards that little girl.
Society often tells single women that something is wrong with them. It isn't. Self-compassion means you stop apologising for your path — and at the same time believe that you deserve love.
This week, do
- Take a self-compassion break once every day.
- Write a letter to yourself.
- Catch one of your inner critical sentences and rephrase it the way you would say it to a friend.
Close the past
Forgiveness isn't a gift to him. It is the key that unlocks you.
As long as a past relationship is an open wound, every new man will stand in its shadow. Closing the past doesn't mean forgetting or excusing. It means taking away its power over your future.
Exercise: the unsent letter
Write a letter to the person who hurt you. Write everything — the anger, the sadness, what you never said. Don't send the letter. Then read it aloud (alone is fine) and destroy it or keep it — whatever feels right. Research on expressive writing shows that writing about painful experiences reduces stress and improves well-being.
Exercise: what I take with me
- What will I never agree to again (my boundaries)?
- Which signs will I recognise sooner next time?
- What good did I take from this relationship (that exists too)?
- What kind of woman have I become because of what I went through?
This week, do
- Write the unsent letter.
- Answer the four "what I take with me" questions.
- Remove one object or photo that reminds you of the pain every day.
Opening up step by step
Fear isn't overcome by thinking. It is overcome by small steps that end well.
Cognitive behavioural therapy, one of the most researched forms of psychotherapy, treats fear of closeness with gradual exposure: step by step you do things that are a little uncomfortable until your brain realises they are safe. Psychologist Arthur Aron showed that closeness between two people grows precisely through mutual, gradual opening up — each person shares a little more than before.
Your ladder of opening up
Start at the bottom and move higher only when a step no longer scares you. Stay on each one until it feels familiar.
| Step | Step |
|---|---|
| 1 | Accept a compliment with "thank you" — without downplaying it |
| 2 | Tell a friend something that really worries you |
| 3 | Ask someone for help |
| 4 | Go on a date with someone you like — and stay until the end |
| 5 | Share something personal about yourself on a date |
| 6 | Tell a man that you like him |
| 7 | Go on a second and third date, even when you're tempted to pull back |
| 8 | Tell him what hurt you in the past |
| 9 | Ask him for something you need ("I'd like you to call me when you're running late") |
| 10 | Say "I love you" or "I'm scared because I care about you" |
Behavioural experiment
Before you take a step, write down: What do I expect to happen? After the step, write down: What actually happened? Compare. Most women find that reality was much kinder than they expected — and that is the evidence the brain needs.
You don't have to look for a new relationship straight away. Start by opening up to friends and family — research shows that more secure attachment is often built in friendships first.
You will climb the ladder more slowly than others, and that's fine. Steps 8–10 may take you longer — trust has to be earned, not given away.
Even step 1 may be hard for you — if you were never praised, accepting a compliment is like learning a foreign language. Keep going; every "thank you" is a new pathway in the brain.
For you, the most important step is 4: going out and staying. Set yourself a goal of one date a month, whether or not he turns out to be "the one". Practice is the goal.
This week, do
- Copy out the ladder and mark which step you are on now.
- Take one step — with a behavioural experiment (expectation versus reality).
Trust is built on evidence
Don't trust words. Trust patterns.
After being hurt, women often think they must choose between "I trust everyone" and "I trust no one". There is a third way: trust that grows with evidence. Research on rebuilding trust shows that it is built by consistent actions, not promises — and that a brain that has learned danger only unlearns it after enough repetitions of safety.
How to build trust in a new man
- Watch for consistency. Does he come when he says he will? Call when he promises? Is he the same on Monday as on Saturday?
- Watch how he treats boundaries. When you say "no" or "slower", does he respect it — without sulking?
- Watch how he talks about others. About his exes, his colleagues, women in general.
- Give it time. For the first three months everyone shows their best side. True character shows under stress, when tired, when disagreeing.
- Trust with your eyes, not with his phone. Checking his phone doesn't build trust — it feeds fear. If you can't trust without checking, that's a sign you need more time or a different man.
Research on rebuilding trust after a major betrayal talks about years, not weeks. With a new man you don't need that long — but you do need to be aware that your vigilance isn't about him. You can tell him: "I was cheated on, so I need a little more clarity. I'm not accusing you — just help me."
Calm and reliability may feel boring at first, because you are used to drama. Give a kind man more chances than you would instinctively — attraction to a safe man often grows only with time.
This week, do
- Write down by which actions (not words) you will know a man is trustworthy.
- With a man you are getting to know (or a friend), watch for consistency and write it down.
When the fear returns in a relationship
It will come back. That isn't failure — it is a chance to do things differently this time.
When a relationship becomes serious, fear often grows stronger: "Now I have something to lose." That's normal. The difference is what you do with it.
Tell him
Not all at once and not on the first date, but as the relationship grows, tell him your story in outline. A man who understands why you sometimes pull back won't take it personally. You can say: "Sometimes I pull back when I care about someone a lot. It isn't because of you — it's my old fear. It helps if you don't leave me alone then and don't push."
When it's triggered
- Name it: "My fear has just been triggered."
- Breathe: slowly, with the out-breath longer than the in-breath, for a few minutes.
- Check the facts: what actually happened?
- Ask instead of defending: "I need a hug" instead of silence or reproach.
An agreement about closeness
If your wounds are also connected with physical closeness, agree with him on a signal at which you both stop — no questions asked and no hurt feelings. Joannides describes how it helps women after bad experiences to set the pace themselves, and that most men are happy to help once they understand. A man who doesn't respect your "stop" isn't the man for you.
Be careful not to punish a new man for the sins of the old one. When you accuse him of something your ex did, tell him: "Sorry, that was my old film, not you."
When you feel the urge to check his phone, say instead: "I'm feeling unsure today." An open conversation builds trust; secret checking destroys it — even if you find nothing.
In a conflict you may feel like you did as a child — small and helpless. Remind yourself that you are now an adult and can leave if it really isn't safe. Paradoxically, knowing this helps you stay.
After years of independence, sharing space and time may bother you. That isn't a sign the relationship is wrong — it's adjustment. Agree on time for yourself.
This week, do
- Write how you would explain your fear to a partner (current or future) in three sentences.
- Practise the four "when it's triggered" steps with every small fear.
When to seek help
Asking for help isn't weakness. It is the first step on the ladder of opening up.
This guide can help with most fears. Professional help is recommended, however, if:
- the past has been hurting you for months so much that it affects your sleep, work or daily life,
- you have intrusive memories, nightmares or panic at closeness,
- you have experienced violence, abuse or rape,
- the pattern keeps repeating however hard you try,
- you often feel emptiness, hopelessness or thoughts of not wanting to live.
Which therapy helps
| Approach | When |
|---|---|
| Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) | Fear of rejection, anxiety, recurring thoughts; gradual exposure |
| EMDR | Traumatic memories (violence, betrayal, accidents) |
| Schema therapy | Deep patterns from childhood ("they will leave me", "I'm not worthy of love") |
| Emotionally focused therapy (EFT) | For couples in which one partner's fear affects the relationship |
Where to turn (in Slovenia; elsewhere, look for the equivalent local services)
- Your GP — a referral to a clinical psychologist or psychiatrist.
- Psychotherapists — a list on the websites of the Slovenian Umbrella Association for Psychotherapy and the Chamber of Psychotherapy.
- Mental distress helpline: 01 520 99 00 (every day from 7 pm to 7 am).
- SOS helpline for women and children — victims of violence: 080 11 55.
- In an emergency: 112.
The 90-day plan
Courage isn't the absence of fear. It is a step despite it — a small one, every day.
Phase 1: Understand (weeks 1–4)
| Week | Tasks |
|---|---|
| 1 | Self-test; "running away" or "running forward"; noticing the body at closeness |
| 2 | Three experiences that taught you fear; is it still true? |
| 3 | The rejection cycle: facts versus interpretations; a one-hour pause before responding |
| 4 | Intuition or fear: a list of real red flags |
Phase 2: Heal (weeks 5–8)
| Week | Tasks |
|---|---|
| 5 | A self-compassion break every day; a letter to yourself |
| 6 | The unsent letter; "what I take with me" |
| 7 | Ladder of opening up: steps 1–2 |
| 8 | Review: repeat the self-test; what has changed? |
Phase 3: Open up (weeks 9–13)
| Week | Tasks |
|---|---|
| 9 | Ladder: steps 3–4 (ask for help, a date until the end) |
| 10 | Ladder: step 5 (something personal on a date); behavioural experiment |
| 11 | Trust criteria based on actions; watching for consistency |
| 12 | Ladder: steps 6–7 ("I like you", a second date despite the fear) |
| 13 | Final self-test; comparison with week 1; a new 90-day goal |
Daily minimum
- One compassionate sentence to yourself.
- One small step of opening up (a compliment, an honest answer, a request).
- When fear grips you: fact or interpretation?
- A few minutes for your body: a walk, breathing, movement.
- Contact with someone close to you.
Tracking sheet
Tick off what you've done every day. The ticks are saved in your browser (only on this device).
| Task | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat | Sun |
|---|
This week: 0 %
In the end
Your fear once protected you. Thank it — and tell it that it can rest now. You won't need it as much any more, because you have something better: the knowledge of how to tell danger from closeness, tenderness towards yourself and the courage for small steps.
Love always carries a risk. But a life without it carries a certainty — the certainty of loneliness. You deserve a risk that is worth taking.
Good luck. Start today — with one small step.
Sources
- Apostolou, M. (2017). Why people stay single: An evolutionary perspective; Apostolou et al. (2020). Singles' reasons for being single.
- Downey, G., & Feldman, S. I. (1996). Implications of rejection sensitivity for intimate relationships; Downey et al. (1998). The self-fulfilling prophecy in close relationships.
- Pepping, C. A. et al. (2025). Diversity in singlehood experiences: Testing an attachment theory model of sub-groups of singles.
- Main, M. — the Adult Attachment Interview and research on earned secure attachment (earned security).
- Neff, K. D. — research on self-compassion and relationships; Sbarra, D. A., Smith, H. L., & Mehl, M. R. (2012). When leaving your ex, love yourself.
- Pennebaker, J. W. — research on expressive writing.
- Aron, A. et al. (1997). The experimental generation of interpersonal closeness.
- Cognitive behavioural therapy for fear of closeness (gradual exposure, behavioural experiments).
- Research on rebuilding trust after betrayal (systematic review, Journal of Family Therapy, 2025).
- Joannides, P. Guide to Getting it On — chapter 89 (summarised).
- Professional articles in Slovenian, English and German on fear of attachment (Bindungsangst).
This guide is not a substitute for psychotherapy. In Slovenia: mental distress helpline 01 520 99 00 · SOS helpline for women and children — victims of violence: 080 11 55 · emergencies: 112. Elsewhere, contact your local helplines.